you're reading...
Allergy-friendly, Cantaloupe-free, Dairy-free, Dessert, Egg-free, Gluten-free, Oat-free, Peanut-free, Recipes, Soy-free, Tomato-free, Vegan, Yeast-free

Thanksgiving 2011 success #1: Gluten-free, vegan, soy-free pumpkin pie!

Thanksgiving 2011 was my first truly allergy-friendly Thanksgiving, so I had to hunt down some new recipes this year. Some of them were huge successes. Only one attempt had to be tossed. And I made a couple of cool discoveries.

Gluten-free, vegan, soy-free pumpkin pie!

My biggest success this year by far was my pumpkin pie. Pumpkin pie is definitely one of my favorite things — if not my top favorite thing — about Thanksgiving. I knew I could make baked apples or something for an allergy-friendly dessert, but I was determined to find a recipe for pumpkin pie that I could eat.

A quick Google search turned up numerous gluten-free pumpkin pie recipes or vegan pumpkin pie recipes. Many that I could eat looked quite complicated or involved a super long list of ingredients. A couple used a prepared gluten-free crust, which I find often have ingredients I can’t or don’t want to eat.

After a moderate amount of recipe analyzing, I settled on the Gluten-Free Goddess’ gluten-free pumpkin pie recipe from 2008. I recognized all the ingredients, it was vegan and soy-free, and I liked the fact that it was a crust-less pie, which just made things simpler. Also, I was encouraged by the throw-everything-in-the-food-processor mentality, as I’ve never made a pumpkin pie in my life. :)

I thoroughly read every single comment and Karina’s replies. I knew I wanted to follow the recipe without making any substitutions to ingredients, but I was unclear about a couple of things, so I wanted to see if they would be addressed in the comments. Here are some tips that I came away with, which I truly believe helped me:

• The ingredients list “1 1/2 cups full fat coconut milk (or vanilla soy/almond milk)” and I wanted to make sure this was canned coconut milk for cooking, not coconut milk from a carton meant for drinking. The only reason I questioned this was because it says you can sub almond milk (or soy milk), which I believe are going to be thinner than canned coconut milk, and I wanted to get the consistency right. After reading through almost all the comments, Karina does indicate she uses canned coconut milk.

• Also, I was a little nervous to cook with buckwheat. I’d never used buckwheat flour before, but I had made Bob’s Red Mill creamy buckwheat cereal, which has a gummy texture, a weird purplish color and not the greatest taste. After reading through all the comments, I noticed a number of buckwheat-related questions or comments about an unpleasant color to the pie, to which Karina responded that she uses Arrowhead Mills buckwheat flour (certified gluten-free) and the brand of buckwheat might make a difference in color, for instance. When I went to Whole Foods to buy my pie ingredients, I checked their bulk foods buckwheat flour. It said “dark” on it, so I promptly hunted down the Arrowhead Mills bag!

• I was a little bit worried the ingredients wouldn’t all fit in my food processor at the same time, so I combined all the dry ingredients in a bowl first and whisked them together, in case I needed to process things a little at a time. But it turned out my processor could take the whole recipe at once! I use a Black & Decker FP1000M, which I believe is a 10-cup model, but I wouldn’t want to fill it any further than what this recipe calls for. (Karina uses a 7-cup model, but it would worry me to use anything smaller.)

• Finally, it helped to know that you have to use a glass pie plate for this recipe. And this part helped me a lot: “The pie should be firm — but still give a little when lightly touched. The center should not be wet. It will fall a bit as it cools.” After half an hour, the pie puffed up much higher in the center than I expected! So I checked it with my finger at the 45-minute, 55-minute, 60-minute and 65-minute marks. Up until the 60-minute or 65-minute mark, there was a dry top to the pie, but I could tell there was a gooey-liquid feel just underneath. My fingerprint stayed for a number of seconds after I touched it. After about 60 or 65 minutes, it felt more solidified and my fingerprint disappeared quickly. I left it in for 65 minutes because Karina mentioned she’s at a higher altitude, so I didn’t know how her experiences would compare to mine.

The center of the pie falls, leaving a crust-like ridge

After letting the pie cool to room temperature, and then sticking it in the fridge overnight, I was almost certain the pie had turned out correctly. The center had fallen, leaving a crust-like effect around the edge. It felt like a pumpkin pie when I touched it.

Cutting into the pie, the piece came away from the dish and the rest of the pie with ease. It held its shape — and it was without a doubt the best pumpkin pie ever! Just as Karina says, you could serve this to pumpkin pie fans with no dietary restrictions and they’d love it, too!

About these ads



  1. Pingback: Thanksgiving 2011 success #2: Gluten-free stuffing « An Impossible Feast - December 2, 2011

  2. Pingback: Holiday potluck dish: Sweet potato casserole « An Impossible Feast - December 14, 2011

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: